Which theories are taught to students and how they are taught: A content analysis of interpreting textbooks

Resumen

The usefulness of theory in interpreter training is widely recognized. Yet descriptive studies on which theories are used and how they are pedagogically treated in training are scant. This study aims at investigating which theories are covered and how they are pedagogically treated in interpreting textbooks. Content analysis was used to code 58 interpreting textbooks against a theory category framework for coverage. The results indicate that 14 theories and 33 categories of insights from the literature are covered in the textbooks. The two most popular theories are the Effort Model and Interpretive Theory, while the highly covered categories of insights from the literature concern the component skills of interpreting. Textbooks that cover the two most popular theories were coded against a pedagogical treatment framework. The results suggest that, although the theories are adequately treated in language presentation and information amount, they are poorly discussed in relation to practice, indicating that the textbooks fail to create situations for students to construct meaningful knowledge of theories from their own interpreting experiences, which is close to a transmissionist approach. Possible reasons for the two theories’ popularity and the impact of a transmissionist approach are discussed against the current literature.

Descargas

Los datos de descargas todavía no están disponibles.

Biografía del autor/a

Xiangdong Li, Xi'an International Studies University

Xiangdong Li is Professor of Applied Linguistics and Translation Studies at Xi’an International Studies University, China. His research interests include language teaching, academic writing, contrastive rhetoric, and translation studies. His research has appeared in English Today, Lingua, Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, Across Languages and Cultures, Translation and Interpreting Studies, Babel, Perspectives, and The Interpreter and Translator Trainer among other scholarly outlets.

Ver citas

Descarga artículo

Crossmark

Métricas

Publicado
2022-10-25
Cómo citar
Yang Y. y Li X. (2022). Which theories are taught to students and how they are taught: A content analysis of interpreting textbooks . Círculo de Lingüística Aplicada a la Comunicación, 92, 167-185. https://doi.org/10.5209/clac.78327